Home » Blog » Comparing Different Natural Gas Brokerage Models

Comparing Different Natural Gas Brokerage Models

September 12, 2025

Navigating natural gas models in the U.S. can be confusing for businesses and homeowners alike. Brokers offer solutions, but their models, commission-based, digital, or concierge, differ widely. Each approach has unique pricing, contracts, and technology tools that impact costs and convenience.

This guide breaks down the key brokerage models and helps you choose the one that fits your needs.

Pricing Structures

Commission-Based

Brokers often add a margin to the wholesale supply price. This margin (typically expressed per unit, e.g., $/MMBtu or ¢/kWh) becomes the broker’s commission. For example, a broker might secure a $0.060/kWh supplier rate and add $0.005/kWh broker fee, yielding a total price of $0.065/kWh. Commission fees are usually paid by the supplier to the broker but are effectively passed on to the customer in the rate.

Flat Fees

Some brokers charge a fixed fee (e.g., a monthly or annual retainer) instead of (or in addition to) a per-unit commission. A flat fee gives the customer predictable costs, but can be less advantageous if energy usage is very high (since the broker has no volume incentive). According to industry guides, flat fees are used by brokers to offer transparency and predictability.

Hybrid Models

Many brokers use a hybrid approach, combining flat fees and commissions. For example, a broker might charge a moderate flat fee plus a smaller commission rate, aligning incentives (broker is still motivated to lower supplier price) while giving some cost stability. Some sources describe hybrid models as balancing broker incentives with predictable costs.

Performance-Based Fees

In rare cases, brokers charge based on a share of the actual cost savings achieved. Under this model, the broker’s compensation is explicitly tied to the money saved versus some baseline price.

Service Models

Full-Service (Traditional) Brokers

These brokers provide end-to-end energy procurement services (rate shopping, contract negotiation, renewal management, market monitoring). They typically build relationships with many suppliers and leverage market expertise for the client. Commercial brokers in particular operate this way, servicing businesses by negotiating favorable supply contracts and earning commissions on the customer’s consumption. Full-service brokers handle paperwork and renewals over the lifetime of the contract. They are common for larger commercial or industrial clients.

Online/Digital Platforms

A growing model is the self-service or “digital broker.” These platforms (often web-based marketplaces) allow customers to compare and lock in rates themselves. For example, one platform “hired a team of software engineers to create a simple experience” where commercial customers can compare electricity (and by extension gas) rates online, bypassing sales pitches. Customers skip back-and-forth sales calls and obtain competitive offers directly from multiple suppliers. Such online brokers are often used by small businesses and residential customers for convenience and speed.

Concierge/White-Glove Services

Some brokerages offer a high-touch “concierge” service model. This involves dedicated account management and hands-on support (e.g. detailed budgeting, on-site audits, renewal alerts). For instance, professional procurement firms advertise “white-glove service” including a smooth onboarding, streamlined billing, and a dedicated U.S.-based representative to resolve issues. Concierge services minimize customer effort (often appealing to large companies or high-tier residential clients) but typically cost more. Examples include utilities concierge for home movers (handling all utility setups) or bespoke brokerages for Fortune 500 energy buyers.

Contract Types

Fixed-Rate Contracts:

Lock in a single price for all consumption over the contract term. This provides budget certainty (no exposure to spot market swings) but forfeits any benefit if market prices fall. Fixed rates are popular for budgeting: customers pay the same rate per therm (gas) or kWh (electricity) each month. A fixed-rate custom offer is based on the customer’s usage profile, but once set it does not change.

Index- or Market-Rate Contracts:

Tied to a publicly published commodity index (e.g., Henry Hub, NYMEX gas). Prices can change (often monthly) as the index moves. Index contracts let customers benefit from price drops, but risk price spikes. In practice, an indexed plan’s price fluctuates “regularly” based on the cost of natural gas, allowing businesses to plan usage around anticipated hourly prices. This can suit customers willing to accept volatility or with flexible usage (e.g., running processes when prices are low).

Blended or Block-and-Index Contracts:

Combine a fixed portion with a variable portion. For example, a customer might fix 50% of its usage at a fixed rate and leave 50% on an index. This hybrid approach gives some budget stability while retaining market exposure on part of the load. Block-and-Index contracts explicitly break consumption into fixed “blocks” and an indexed remainder. This is useful for 24/7 operations (e.g., manufacturers can fix on-peak usage at a hedge and let off-peak float).

Blend-and-Extend Contracts:

Adjust an existing fixed contract by blending in a new lower rate. For example, if mid-contract market prices drop, a blend-and-extend lets the customer extend the contract term by averaging the old fixed price with the new lower price, yielding an intermediate rate. This immediately reduces costs without waiting for the old contract to end. It’s a way to lock in current low prices partly through the remaining term.

Technology and Tools

Digital Quoting Engines

Modern brokers use online platforms with live market data. According to industry analysts, a powerful pricing engine can rapidly produce professional quotes by pulling live index feeds (e.g. daily gas prices) and pre-set margin rules. These systems let brokers generate on-the-spot quotes for any contract type – from simple fixed residential rates to complex industrial deals – with real-time price accuracy.

Customer Portals

Many brokerages offer web portals or mobile apps where clients can view quotes, compare supplier offers, and manage accounts. For residential customers, portals allow plan shopping and enrollment online. For commercial clients, portals may include usage analytics, alert dashboards, and the ability to launch e-RFPs (requests for proposals) to suppliers. One software provider notes that brokers can now submit a custom price request to multiple suppliers with a click and manage all quotes from a single dashboard.

Real-Time Pricing and Auctions

Brokers increasingly harness real-time data feeds. Platforms can pull live index prices via APIs to update quotes instantly. Some brokers even run reverse auctions; large customers put out an opportunity and multiple suppliers bid live on the contract, driving down prices in real time. These digital innovations give tech-savvy customers faster, more transparent price discovery.

Commercial vs Residential Impact

Small-to-Midsize Businesses (SMBs)

Often lack in-house energy expertise, so a broker’s market knowledge can save time and secure better rates. Many SMBs choose full-service or online brokers to avoid direct shopping.

Large/Industrial Customers

They consume huge volumes and may negotiate directly with suppliers to leverage volume discounts. Large firms often have energy providers or consultants. However, even big customers may still use a specialized broker or consultant for complex structuring (hedging, peak-shaving) because “sophisticated brokers can lend market guidance” on pricing and contract design. In summary, large commercial users prioritize customization and scale, while smaller businesses prioritize convenience and broad market access.

Residential Customers (Homes)

Individual households use far less energy, so savings per account are smaller. Residential energy brokers operate differently; they need a very high volume (many customers) to make a living. They often sell simplified rate plans (e.g., fixed 12-month, variable month-to-month) through door-to-door or online marketing. Homeowners typically seek price stability or small incentives (e.g., gift cards, in-home devices) rather than complex contracts. Because residential bills are relatively low, many homeowners pick a fixed-rate plan online or stay on the utility’s default rate. Some states have online marketplaces for home customers, reflecting an online platform model. Overall, residential buyers value ease of sign-up and clear price (cited as “homeowner perks” and fixed below-utility rates).

Benefits and Drawbacks

Commission-Based Models:

Pros: Aligns broker incentives with customer price: a broker is motivated to find a low supplier rate to maximize volume. It requires no upfront fee from the customer.
Cons: Commission is often embedded in the price (possibly a higher rate than wholesale). The customer must trust the broker’s motives (some brokers may steer clients to suppliers that pay higher commissions). Transparency can be an issue if commission rates are not disclosed.

Flat-Fee Models:

Pros: Predictable costs (flat monthly/annual fee) make budgeting easy and avoid surprise markups.
Cons: Brokers may have less motivation to find the lowest possible price once their fee is covered. High-usage customers may pay more overall if the flat fee is large relative to their savings.

Full-Service Brokers:

Pros: Provide expert market analysis, save the customer time, and navigate complex contract terms. They can access dozens of suppliers and negotiate better terms on behalf of the client.
Cons: Service fees or commissions increase the overall cost. The customer gives up direct control and must trust the broker’s recommendations. Quality varies between brokers.

Online Platforms:

Pros: Instant comparison shopping with minimal effort. Often lower cost since they automate processes. Highly transparent rates (you see the exact price offered). Convenient for residential and small business customers.
Cons: Limited or no personalized advice. Usually only handle standard fixed/variable plans (less ability to negotiate custom deals). May not serve very large or complex accounts.

Concierge Services:

Pros: Highest level of service, dedicated account reps, proactive management, streamlined billing, and saving time for the client. Often includes value-added services like market reports or utility management.
Cons: Usually come with premium fees. Overkill for simple or low-volume needs (better suited to large enterprises or wealthy homeowners).

Choosing the Right Model (Scenarios)

Small Businesses & Consumers

If your annual usage is modest (say, under a few hundred MMBtu or kWh), a simple fixed-rate plan from a supplier or an online broker is often best. This model offers predictable bills with minimal effort. Working with a full-service broker may save a few dollars, but their commission might outweigh the benefits for low usage. For homeowners, using state-run choice portals or aggregator websites can help find good deals with little risk.

Mid-Sized Businesses

Companies without dedicated energy staff can benefit from a broker’s expertise. A full-service broker or a commission-based deal can secure better contracts than a DIY approach. If budgeting is critical, insist on clear fee structures (flat or disclosed commission). Using digital platforms (price portals) can also help compare quotes quickly.

Large Industrial Customers

With high volumes, negotiating directly with suppliers can yield deep discounts. Such customers often have in-house Energy Brokerage teams and may prefer to customize terms (e.g. tailored transportation or storage deals). They might use brokers only for market intelligence or hedging strategies. For example, a factory with 24/7 operations might split volume into fixed blocks and index blocks (block-and-index contract) to optimize costs. Concierge-level service or full consultancy is fitting for very large users needing continuous management.

Price-Volatile Environments

If the market is expected to be volatile, consider indexed or blended contracts. A hybrid broker model (low commission + some fixed fee) can ensure the broker still seeks low prices while giving you some upfront price stability.

Technology-Minded Buyers

Businesses comfortable with digital tools should leverage real-time platforms. Customers can get the best of both worlds by using a tech-enabled broker: they benefit from sophisticated quoting software (live index data, auctions) while still having expert guidance. For instance, brokers using live API feeds can instantly show the effect of market changes on contract prices.

Get Expert Natural Gas Brokerage Services Today

Looking for a simpler way to navigate U.S. natural gas options? Great Energy1 offers professional energy brokerage services tailored to your needs, whether you’re a business or a homeowner. We help you compare rates, choose the best contracts, and leverage technology tools to save time and money. Let us handle the complexity so you can focus on what matters most. Contact us today to get started!